Bain vs BCG vs McKinseyConsulting 3
Analyst
What does the workforce data show across McKinsey, BCG, and Bain?
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
McKinsey: 36,135 employees, -6% YoY growth (the only firm shrinking in the set), 28% attrition (highest of the three by 9-10 points), 8,238 hires, 460 open jobs (1.3% of base). All five top growing skills are negative: Econometrics -4%, Python -5%, R -6%, Financial Economics -7%, C -8%.

BCG: 39,369 employees (the largest of the three), +11% YoY growth, 18% attrition, 10,569 hires, 1,134 open jobs (2.9% of base). Top growing skills are positive: Microsoft BI Suite +16%, Power Apps +16%, Power BI +16%, Python +13%, Data Visualization +12%.

Bain: 21,600 employees (smallest of the three), +6% YoY growth, 19% attrition, 4,975 hires, 343 open jobs (1.6% of base). Top growing skills are the highest in absolute terms: Power Apps +24%, JavaScript +22%, MS BI Suite +22%, Power BI +21%, HTML +17%.

Talent Moat Score: BCG 63, Bain 61, McKinsey 44. McKinsey sits 17-19 points below BCG and Bain on the composite.

Note on McKinsey's attrition number: part of the 28% attrition and -6% growth reflects the 2024 layoffs, so some of the attrition is structurally forced. The negative growing skills are not a layoff artifact — those reflect skills no longer being developed inside the firm.

MBB Workforce Snapshot — 2026

36,135
McKinsey Employees
-6% YoY (shrinking)
39,369
BCG Employees
+11% YoY (now largest)
21,600
Bain Employees
+6% YoY
28%
McKinsey Attrition
Highest — partly layoff-driven
18%
BCG Attrition
MBB median
19%
Bain Attrition
MBB median

Talent Moat Score — MBB Direct Comparison

FirmAcquisition (20)Retention (20)Skills (20)Intent (20)Pedigree (20)Total
BCG12516121863
Bain1252061861
McKinsey125361844

Talent Moat Score — Visual

63
61
44
BCG
Bain
McKinsey
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Walk me through the declining growing-skills signal at McKinsey.
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
McKinsey's top growing skills, all negative:
- Econometrics: -4%
- Python: -5%
- R: -6%
- Financial Economics: -7%
- C (programming): -8%

All five are quantitative or technical capabilities. Python and R are the operating languages of QuantumBlack and broader data analytics work. Econometrics and Financial Economics underpin economics, public policy, and corporate finance practices. C is core to software / systems engineering.

Same metric at BCG: MS BI Suite +16%, Power Apps +16%, Power BI +16%, Python +13%, Data Visualization +12%. All five positive, all technical.

Same metric at Bain: Power Apps +24%, JavaScript +22%, MS BI Suite +22%, Power BI +21%, HTML +17%. All five positive. Bain's HTML and JavaScript signals are distinctive — front-end and customer-facing application capability appearing in a strategy firm's top skill mix.

The cross-firm number to anchor on: Python. McKinsey -5%, BCG +13%. McKinsey's Python-skilled population is shrinking; BCG's is growing at 13% YoY. The other AI/ML-adjacent skills (R, Econometrics) move in the same direction.

Top Growing Skills by Firm

#McKinseyBCGBain
1Econometrics (-4%)MS BI Suite (+16%)MS Power Apps (+24%)
2Python (-5%)MS Power Apps (+16%)JavaScript (+22%)
3R (-6%)MS Power BI (+16%)MS BI Suite (+22%)
4Financial Economics (-7%)Python (+13%)MS Power BI (+21%)
5C Programming (-8%)Data Visualization (+12%)HTML (+17%)

Top Growing Skills — Net Direction by Firm

5 of 5 NEGATIVE
McKinsey Top Skills
Capability contraction
5 of 5 POSITIVE
BCG Top Skills
Broad technical build
5 of 5 POSITIVE
Bain Top Skills
Most aggressive build (24% top)
McKinsey gap widening
Strategic Implication
36-month risk to AI/data positioning
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Show me the inter-firm talent flows across McKinsey, BCG, and Bain.
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights

BCG — Top Inflows & Outflows

Hiring From
Deloitte
113
Accenture
91
EY
86
McKinsey
57
PwC
55
BCG
Departures To
39
Bain
37
Google
35
Deloitte
34
McKinsey
33
EY

Bain — Top Inflows & Outflows

Hiring From
Deloitte
64
Accenture
51
EY
49
McKinsey
34
Kearney
32
Bain
Departures To
47
BCG
46
Alvarez & Marsal
27
Goldman Sachs
0
EY-Parthenon
0
Deloitte

McKinsey — Top Inflows & Outflows

Hiring From
Deloitte
79
EY
56
Accenture
49
BCG
41
Amazon
37
McKinsey
Departures To
52
BCG
50
Google
36
Amazon
34
Bain
37
Deloitte
Inter-firm flows from McKinsey:
- McKinsey ↔ BCG: McKinsey lost 52 to BCG, hired 41 from BCG → net -11 to BCG
- McKinsey ↔ Bain: McKinsey lost 34 to Bain, hired 0 captured → net -34 to Bain

Inter-firm flows from BCG:
- BCG ↔ Bain: BCG lost 39 to Bain; net direction likely positive based on inflows captured
- BCG ↔ McKinsey: BCG hired 57 from McKinsey, lost 34 to McKinsey → net +23 from McKinsey
- BCG ↔ Big 4: net +78 from Deloitte, +91 from Accenture, +53 from EY

Inter-firm flows from Bain:
- Bain ↔ BCG: Bain lost 47 to BCG, hired 0 captured → net -47 to BCG
- Bain ↔ McKinsey: Bain hired 34 from McKinsey, lost 0 captured → net +34 from McKinsey
- Bain ↔ PE / IB: net -46 to Alvarez & Marsal, -27 to Goldman Sachs

Net positions across the three:
- BCG: +23 from McKinsey, ~+30 vs Bain — net positive across both peers and across Big 4
- Bain: +34 from McKinsey, -47 to BCG — net positive vs McKinsey, net negative vs BCG, net outflow to PE / IB
- McKinsey: -11 to BCG, -34 to Bain — net negative against both peers
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Pull the Big Tech outflow data across the three firms.
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
Big Tech outflows captured by firm (trailing 12 months):
- McKinsey: net -50 to Google, -36 to Amazon. Total visible Big Tech net loss ~ -50.
- BCG: -37 to Google. No major Amazon outflow captured.
- Bain: No major Big Tech outflows captured in the top destinations.

Bain's named outflow concentrations sit in PE / IB instead: -46 to Alvarez & Marsal, -27 to Goldman Sachs.

McKinsey shows the largest Big Tech outflow of the three. Bain's outflows sit in PE / IB. BCG's outflows are smaller in volume and split between Big Tech and Big 4.

MBB Outflows to Big Tech (trailing 12 months)

Firm→ Google→ AmazonTotal Big Tech LossAlumni Conversion Signal
McKinsey50 net36 (1 net)HighestTech-heavy → revenue conversion risk
BCG37Not in topModerateIndustry-balanced — better conversion
BainNot in topNot in topLow capturedPE-heavy — strongest revenue conversion
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
What does the school pedigree data show across the three firms?
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
Top 5 schools by firm:
- McKinsey: INSEAD, Wharton, LSE, Harvard Business School, Oxford.
- BCG: Wharton, LSE, INSEAD, Bocconi, HBS.
- Bain: INSEAD, Wharton, Bocconi, HBS, Kellogg.

INSEAD, Wharton, and HBS appear in all three top-5 lists.

Where the lists differ:
- McKinsey is the only one with Oxford in the top 5. McKinsey and BCG both include LSE.
- BCG and Bain both include Bocconi (Milan, finance-heavy). McKinsey does not.
- Bain is the only one with Kellogg in the top 5 (consumer / operations focus).

All three firms recruit from overlapping elite MBA pools at the top; the distinctive schools at the margin are Oxford (McKinsey only), Bocconi (BCG and Bain), and Kellogg (Bain only).

MBB Top Schools — Recruiting Source Comparison

#McKinseyBCGBain
1INSEADWhartonINSEAD
2WhartonLSEWharton
3LSEINSEADBocconi
4Harvard Business SchoolBocconiHarvard Business School
5OxfordHarvard Business SchoolKellogg
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
What do the AI / data skill numbers look like at the firm level — QuantumBlack vs BCG X vs Bain Vector?
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
BCG X (BCG): BCG's top growing skills are MS BI Suite +16%, Power Apps +16%, Power BI +16%, Python +13%, Data Visualization +12%. All five positive, all technical/analytics. BCG's net inflows include +78 from Deloitte, +91 from Accenture (consulting talent moving into BCG at scale).

Bain Vector / Bain Innovation & Design (Bain): Bain's top growing skills are Power Apps +24%, JavaScript +22%, MS BI Suite +22%, Power BI +21%, HTML +17%. The HTML and JavaScript signals indicate front-end / customer-facing application capability — a skill mix not typical of strategy firms.

QuantumBlack (McKinsey): McKinsey's top growing skills are all negative: Python -5%, R -6%, C -8%, Econometrics -4%, Financial Economics -7%. These are the skill domains QuantumBlack is built around.

Cross-firm comparison on AI/data skill direction:
- BCG: five positive technical skills, +12% to +16%
- Bain: five positive technical skills, +17% to +24%
- McKinsey: five negative technical skills, -4% to -8%

AI / Data Skill Growth — Firm Comparison

BCG (BCG X)
Healthy
Top growth skillMS BI +16%
Capability spreadBroad
IntegrationMature

WINNING — broadest tech build in MBB

Bain (Vector)
Healthy
Top growth skillPower Apps +24%
Capability spreadAggressive
IntegrationBuilding

RISING — fastest skills growth, smaller base

McKinsey (QuantumBlack)
Alert
Top growth skillAll NEGATIVE
Capability spreadContracting
BrandStrong (still)

AT RISK — brand intact, capability eroding

How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Stack-rank the largest gaps the data shows at McKinsey.
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
Stack-ranked, the largest gaps in McKinsey's talent data:

Gap 1: technical / AI skills are declining at McKinsey while growing at peers. Python -5%, R -6%, C -8%, Econometrics -4%, Financial Economics -7%. BCG and Bain show all five of their top growing skills positive in the same skill domain (Python +13% at BCG; Power Apps +24%, JavaScript +22% at Bain).

Gap 2: net talent outflow to peer firms. McKinsey is net -11 to BCG and net -34 to Bain in the trailing 12-month captured flows. McKinsey did not capture any inflow from Bain back to McKinsey.

Gap 3: Big Tech outflow. McKinsey's named outflow concentrations include -50 to Google and -36 to Amazon — the largest visible Big Tech outflow of the three firms.

Gap 4: attrition at 28%, the highest of the three firms. Part of this reflects the 2024 layoffs (structurally forced); the remainder runs ahead of BCG (18%) and Bain (19%).

Gap 5: headcount direction. McKinsey is the only firm in the set with negative YoY growth (-6%). BCG +11%, Bain +6%.

Where the data is strongest at McKinsey. Top-5 school list still leads in academic prestige (INSEAD, Wharton, LSE, HBS, Oxford). Hires volume (8,238) is second only to BCG (10,569). The 460 open jobs (1.3% of base) is the lowest open-job rate of the three.
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Pull the Open-to-Work signal across the three firms.
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
Open-to-Work headline numbers (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026):
- McKinsey: 30% OTW (11,000 of 37,000 captured profiles) — highest rate of the three.
- BCG: 28% OTW (11,000 of 40,000) — same absolute count as McKinsey on a larger base.
- Bain: 27% OTW (6,000 of 22,000) — lowest rate.

All three firms sit between 27% and 30% on Open-to-Work share.

Rediscovered candidates by firm:
- McKinsey: 88 rediscovered (2.4 per 1,000 employees)
- BCG: 67 rediscovered (1.7 per 1,000 employees)
- Bain: 87 rediscovered (4.0 per 1,000 employees)

Bain has the lowest public Open-to-Work rate but the highest rediscovered-candidate density per 1,000 employees.

McKinsey skill-level Open-to-Work concentrations:
- Strategy: 6,200 OTW (34% of the 18,000 Strategy-skilled population)
- M&A: 788 OTW (34% of the M&A-skilled cohort)

Skill-level detail across all three firms follows.
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback
Analyst
Show me the skill-level Open-to-Work pattern across the three firms. Where is each firm's signal concentrated?
LinkedIn Talent Data Insights
Skill-by-skill Open-to-Work rate (across the three firms):
- Data Analytics: McKinsey 42%, BCG 37%, Bain 36%
- Operations Management: McKinsey 41%, BCG 35%, Bain 33%
- Financial Analysis: McKinsey 39%, BCG 35%, Bain 33%
- Strategy: McKinsey 34%, BCG 32%, Bain 30%
- Management Consulting: McKinsey 34%, BCG 31%, Bain 29%
- M&A: McKinsey 34%, BCG 33%, Bain 33%

McKinsey runs the highest OTW% in every skill category in the comparison.

Absolute OTW pool sizes for the top McKinsey concentrations:
- Data Analytics: 3,100 at McKinsey (42%), 2,400 at BCG (37%), 1,400 at Bain (36%)
- Strategy: 6,200 at McKinsey (34%), comparable shares at BCG and Bain
- M&A: 788 at McKinsey, 720 at BCG, 556 at Bain — 2,064 combined across the three

Per-firm skill detail follows.

McKinsey & Company Open-to-Work Aggregate (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

37,000
Employees on LinkedIn
Total McKinsey & Company captured profiles
11,000
Open to Work
30% of captured profiles
4,300
Active talent
12% — actively job-searching
88
Rediscovered candidates
Engaged with recruiters previously

McKinsey & Company Open-to-Work by Skill (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

SkillCapturedOpen to Work% OTWActive talent% Active
Strategy18,0006,20034%2,60014%
Management Consulting21,0007,10034%2,80013%
Financial Analysis8,8003,40039%1,60018%
Mergers & Acquisitions2,30078834%42719%
Data Analytics7,3003,10042%1,40019%
Project Management18,0006,70037%2,90016%
Operations Management10,0004,10041%1,90019%
Marketing11,0004,20038%1,80016%

Boston Consulting Group Open-to-Work Aggregate (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

40,000
Employees on LinkedIn
Total Boston Consulting Group captured profiles
11,000
Open to Work
28% of captured profiles
4,400
Active talent
11% — actively job-searching
67
Rediscovered candidates
Engaged with recruiters previously

Boston Consulting Group Open-to-Work by Skill (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

SkillCapturedOpen to Work% OTWActive talent% Active
Strategy18,0005,80032%2,80016%
Management Consulting27,0008,50031%3,80014%
Financial Analysis9,5003,30035%1,60017%
Mergers & Acquisitions2,20072033%40618%
Data Analytics6,5002,40037%1,20018%
Project Management19,0006,20033%3,00016%
Operations Management10,0003,50035%1,80018%
Marketing12,0004,00033%1,90016%

Bain & Company Open-to-Work Aggregate (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

22,000
Employees on LinkedIn
Total Bain & Company captured profiles
6,000
Open to Work
27% of captured profiles
2,400
Active talent
11% — actively job-searching
87
Rediscovered candidates
Engaged with recruiters previously

Bain & Company Open-to-Work by Skill (LinkedIn Recruiter, May 1 2026 data)

SkillCapturedOpen to Work% OTWActive talent% Active
Strategy11,0003,30030%1,60015%
Management Consulting12,0003,50029%1,60013%
Financial Analysis5,5001,80033%94617%
Mergers & Acquisitions1,70055633%35221%
Data Analytics3,9001,40036%79220%
Project Management9,2003,10034%1,50016%
Operations Management5,1001,70033%92418%
Marketing7,5002,30031%1,10015%
How valuable were this section's answers?
click 👍 / 👎 to leave feedback

Continue the analysis

How valuable were this section's answers?

Helpful, missed the mark, or somewhere in between? Tell me what you'd want more or less of.

Not at all helpfulExtremely helpful
Prefer email? raybould@gmail.com